Testosterone Nation
SEARCH

Advanced | Members

HOME    T-NATION FORUMS    TMUSCLE STORE     LOG IN
TMUSCLE Store
Flameout

Does Judo Work in a Street Fight
Rating
1 2 | Next Last
 

WWEAttitude
Level 0

Join date: Jan 2010
Location:
Posts: 20

Hey i've been checking out some judo vids lately on youtube and am starting to get into the sport, just want to know though if it works in a street fight, and also how much stand-up grappling and groundwork are you taught when u compare it to throws, since it seems like its more of a takedown-oriented sport from the vids i've seen.

Report Post
 

FightinIrish26
Level 0

Join date: Feb 2005
Location: New Jersey, USA
Posts: 11048

Judo is great, one of the most underrated MA's in this world that focuses now on BJJ.

Judo is one of the best grappling arts for the street because of it's focus on takedowns instead of groundfighting- and those throws can end a fight in one shot. A couple of my favorite chokes come from judo as well. If you've got te oppurtunity to take some classes, go for it.

Report Post
 

jtrinsey
Level 3

Join date: Nov 2005
Location:
Posts: 2737

I only have a limited experience with Judo. There are more serious players here who would be able to give you a full rundown.

I will say that the coaches at our MMA gym do a "streetfighting" class that, while being kind of bullshit in a way, is also a lot of fun. A lot of the focus is on what to do if somebody grabs you from behind or grabs you by the collar or two guys attack you, etc.

One of the coaches has a strong background in Judo and I will say that some of the moves are ruthless in those situations. Part of it is that he is a good athlete with awesome technique. But if somebody comes up behind you and grabs you, it's not a bad thing to be able to twist and throw them to the ground and run away.

Also, since so much of the sport involves grabbing, throwing, etc., I think it would eliminate the "freeze" instinct that some people have when they get grabbed.

Report Post
 

666Rich
Level 0

Join date: May 2006
Location: Pennsylvania, USA
Posts: 261

Probably one of the best arts for the street. Gi's are easily replaced by shirts, jackets, etc, so gripping is not that much of a problem. Throws are devestating on any surface, most people dont know how to breakfall. Footsweeps are easy to get and efficient, not as lethal.

My friend wrestled in college. In wrestling he beats me bad. however if hes wearing a hoodie, I can stuff him and take down pretty easy.

It is a very position oriented sport so once you get TD you can pound the shit out of someone. Thats why i prefer it to BJJ.

Watch a top judo guy throw someone and you will see how awsome this sport is. The tall Korean guy in my avatar was one of the founders of Judo in the US. He threw Jon Bluming around...if you know who that is. Look it up. Kyu Ha Kim is the name.

Report Post
 

Schwarzfahrer
Level 0

Join date: Jun 2005
Location: Germany
Posts: 2028

Yep, Judo's very legit.
Since it's very popular in Germany, we have a lot of wussy dojos, more suited to children.
But real Judo is fantastic for the clinch & beyond.

Big strengths: throws, ukemi, explosivness & power, establishing top control after both guys go to the floor, also: some nice locks (never a bad thing to pin assholes without the need to crush them with your weight).


Bonus excursion: what is realism
We had, not long ago here on this board, a conversation about how realistic (boxing) body shots are. And that trying to liverhook a guy with a thick leather jacket is different then doing that in the ring.
Essentially, it's a similar discussion to BJJ with gi/no gi.
What is suited to MMA doesn't have to be realistic per se.
Now a good Judo player is one of the few TMA guys who constantly train in an extremely realistic environment, throwing wise, BECAUSE of the dogi.
And that doesn't stop at throws. For example, most people, even streetfighters, have little knowledge or respect for gi-chokes.

That might be different if you hang out and work at a sunny beach 90% of your time.
Then turkish oil wrestling might be just the thing for you.

Report Post
 

mmllcc
Level 4

Join date: Dec 2006
Location:
Posts: 687

Wrestling is good, MMA, Grappling, etc is good -- and Judo is also good. I have seen two street fights with two different Judo practitioners against two different rough looking "street fighters" and they lasted but a few seconds. Getting thrown on to cement hurts - a lot. So in my limited experience, Judo worked great.

Report Post
 

HolyMacaroni
Level 2

Join date: Sep 2008
Location: Alabama, USA
Posts: 3650

i love this vid




i watched a guy grab another guys jacked with both hands, pull him in for a headbutt, and then do a hip throw while holding the guys jacket.

i'd say it was pretty effective

Report Post
 

kmcnyc
Level 0

Join date: Nov 2006
Location: New York, USA
Posts: 3377

Judo is pretty effective in the 'streetz' for most of the reasons every one has mentioned

Training Judo can really help with doing stuff for you.
Like giving you a great grip, developing some really good ways to deal with people who grab you
or are close enough to be grabed, and for developing some great balance

Ive played judo for a long time so maybe I can help you a little bit, Most Judo schools do put an emphasis on the throws, the Nagewaza.
You want to find a place that puts a good balance on that and Newazza the 'ground work' that we do.

With all MA's they can help- but don't go picking fights :)
and with all MA's go see the school in person , they are happy to let you watch a class or classes.

Report Post
 

Sentoguy
Level 2

Join date: Nov 2005
Location:
Posts: 4137

If it's a cold weather scenario (opponent is wearing a jacket or hoodie) Judo works very well for throwing/takedowns. If it's a hot weather scenario (guy is in wife beater or shirtless), then you're probably better off with wrestling. Sure, some Judo schools address methods of adapting judo to "no gi" scenarios, but a lot don't. Both will complement each other though.

One of the advantages that Judo has over say BJJ IMO (as far as street combat) is that many Judo throws allow you to remain standing (which is good in a street fight as it allows you to escape the situation easier) while most of the takedowns in BJJ that I've seen result in your going to the ground with the opponent.

On the flip side though, BJJ (as a whole) tends to be more proficient in terms of finishing once it does hit the ground.

So all 3 arts (Judo, wrestling, and BJJ) can all be beneficial arts if you're looking to be able to defend yourself in a real fight.

Report Post
 

FrozenNinja
Level 2

Join date: May 2009
Location: Florida, USA
Posts: 147

In one word....YES! Judo can end a find in one toss! Why don't you also look into a martial art that I do if your interested. It combines throws and striking. Its called Sanshou.

Report Post
 

Aussie Davo
Level 0

Join date: Jan 2009
Location:
Posts: 197

Yes. I've seen a fight ended with one sweet ass shoulder throw that had the instigator on his ass before he knew what he had gotten in to.

I've always maintained that Boxing + Judo would be a potent combination for self defence.

My thoughts on the matter echo much of what Fightin already said. Also, assholes in bars love to escalate by shoving or grabbing clothing before they actually strike you, and judo comes in handy in a tight space like that.

Report Post
 

Aussie Davo
Level 0

Join date: Jan 2009
Location:
Posts: 197

Schwarzfahrer wrote:
Bonus excursion: what is realism
We had, not long ago here on this board, a conversation about how realistic (boxing) body shots are. And that trying to liverhook a guy with a thick leather jacket is different then doing that in the ring.


Are we talking different in the sense that his leather jacket would perhaps hinder the penetration needed to strike the liver? Or just in the sense that it's for some reason harder to perform in a "real" fight? If it's the latter, I fail to see how. I am interested in the discussion though, got a link by any chance?

Report Post
 

666Rich
Level 0

Join date: May 2006
Location: Pennsylvania, USA
Posts: 261

Boxing + judo coming right up, this guys a beast



And for what its worth, i PREFER body shots in a street fight. No lawsuits, and people stay down longer.

Report Post
 

WRATHfight69
Level 0

Join date: Jul 2009
Location: Illinois, USA
Posts: 35

This thread should be good! To answer the Q: YESSSS! emphatically yes any kind of submission grappling or ground game is an excellent advantage! Street fighting was my thing b4 my wife convinced me 2 go ligit and it is always true that blunt force trauma will be your best friend,

there isn't a mat in a parking lot back alley so when you get slammed on your head on concrete,gravel, even dirt there is a major difference along with being on the pavement and working in submissions it of hurts just as much for you as your opponent so throws and mountings are the way to go! As for body shots i dont see why theres an issue if you got the opportunity to strike your opponent you fuckn do it!

Report Post
 

HolyMacaroni
Level 2

Join date: Sep 2008
Location: Alabama, USA
Posts: 3650

WRATHfight69 wrote:
Street fighting was my thing b4 my wife convinced me 2 go ligit


to bad she didn't convince you to finish high school

to legit to quit!!!!

Report Post
 

Kevin_Meaux
Level 2

Join date: Apr 2008
Location:
Posts: 56

Falling down hurts :(

Report Post
 

cycobushmaster
Level 1

Join date: Sep 2004
Location: Iowa, USA
Posts: 1062

HolyMacaroni wrote:
WRATHfight69 wrote:
Street fighting was my thing b4 my wife convinced me 2 go ligit


to bad she didn't convince you to finish high school

to legit to quit!!!!


great....now i got that MC Hammer song stuck in my head

Report Post
 

cycobushmaster
Level 1

Join date: Sep 2004
Location: Iowa, USA
Posts: 1062

WWEAttitude wrote:
Hey i've been checking out some judo vids lately on youtube and am starting to get into the sport, just want to know though if it works in a street fight, and also how much stand-up grappling and groundwork are you taught when u compare it to throws, since it seems like its more of a takedown-oriented sport from the vids i've seen.


while i have little formal training in judo, we do throws similar to it in jujitsu where i train, and when i was growing up and studied karate we trained in them as well.

as a police officer, judo-type throws are really all i use...occasionally i use an akido wrist lock thingy (yeah, that's not the technical term, i'm sure), but otherwise i use a hip toss, or hip toss with a leg sweep. about half the time i've used these, i've knocked people out, or close enough where i was able to handcuff them with no resistance.

obviously striking is important for self-defense, but i think basic judo is a great start.

Report Post
 

legendaryblaze
Level 0

Join date: Jun 2009
Location: Prince Edward Island, CAN
Posts: 601

HolyMacaroni wrote:
WRATHfight69 wrote:
Street fighting was my thing b4 my wife convinced me 2 go ligit


to bad she didn't convince you to finish high school

to legit to quit!!!!


Oh, the IRON-KNEE.

TOO, NOT TO.
"TOO LEGIT TO QUIT".

YOU FUEL.

Report Post
 

HolyMacaroni
Level 2

Join date: Sep 2008
Location: Alabama, USA
Posts: 3650

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAH

Report Post
 

ether_bunny
Level 0

Join date: Oct 2008
Location: Oregon, USA
Posts: 26

It seems every drunken fight always starts with the same sequence. One guy shoves another repeatedly, trying to instigate him into throwing a punch, or just to psyche himself up.

Don't shove judoka, or anyone else who spend hours practicing taking a shove and turning it into a hip throw.

Jackets are nice. Very, very nice. But if there's no jacket, an ippon seoi nage or ogoshi are more than adequate.

And yeah, perfect point, about leaving you up, while he's down. So you can run like hell.

Especially if you managed to careen him off of a fire hydrant. And are in a mad panic because you think you just killed him.

Just don't be thinking so hard how, in the future, you'll avoiding mouthing off ever again like that, and how you're too pretty to go to prison, you run into the side of a bus stop.

Report Post
 

aftercareamerica
Level 0

Join date: Feb 2008
Location:
Posts: 26


I just beat myself in the head and scream like Rainman in the airport....it works great and afterwards people by you drinks and girls think it hilarious...give it a try

LOL...yeah a judo throw onto the concrete or anywhere theres not a mat to protect the person....ouchhhhhh!!!! hello broken bones....

Report Post
 

BAdWolf
Level 0

Join date: Oct 2008
Location:
Posts: 151

I strongly belive that judo is way better for streetfighting-self defense than BJJ at least.

Just think about it: If you'd be facing 3 stalkers would your really try to pull guard to one of them? You'll be kicked as fuck if you do so.

Judo focuses on throws, if you throw an atacker who doesn't know how to perform an ukemi (a safe landing) in the solid floor, he may get a serius head trauma. Or at least putting him on a disadvantaged position so you can finish him with an armbar or whatever.

But, I'll play devil's advocate a little by saying that i belive that "olympic judo" or competitive judo, is not optimal for this propouse. You'll do better by finding a specializated self defense judo dojo.

Good luck ;)

Report Post
 

ether_bunny
Level 0

Join date: Oct 2008
Location: Oregon, USA
Posts: 26

BAdWolf wrote:
I strongly belive that judo is way better for streetfighting-self defense than BJJ at least.

Just think about it: If you'd be facing 3 stalkers would your really try to pull guard to one of them? You'll be kicked as fuck if you do so.

Judo focuses on throws, if you throw an atacker who doesn't know how to perform an ukemi (a safe landing) in the solid floor, he may get a serius head trauma. Or at least putting him on a disadvantaged position so you can finish him with an armbar or whatever.

But, I'll play devil's advocate a little by saying that i belive that "olympic judo" or competitive judo, is not optimal for this propouse. You'll do better by finding a specializated self defense judo dojo.

Good luck ;)


True, but that's what I love best about judo. Please don't flame me, but I really look down on anything that likes to pervade an air of pseudo-mysticism, or take itself too seriously. Judo is a sport, like boxing, or even muai thai. And unlike the other two, it's a sport best practiced by little old pot-bellied people with a few too many drinks in them.

Report Post
 

Sentoguy
Level 2

Join date: Nov 2005
Location:
Posts: 4137

ether_bunny wrote:
True, but that's what I love best about judo. Please don't flame me, but I really look down on anything that likes to pervade an air of pseudo-mysticism, or take itself too seriously. Judo is a sport, like boxing, or even muai thai. And unlike the other two, it's a sport best practiced by little old pot-bellied people with a few too many drinks in them.


???

Report Post
1 2 | Next Last